The following pastors have served the First Presbyterian Church of Lake Park:
| Rev. T.S. Bailey | Organizing Pastor |
Rev. M.T. Rainier Rev. M.T. Rainer and family | 1892-1893 |
| Rev. Joseph Mapson | 1896 |
| Rev. J. Peck | 1897 |
| Rev. James Vallier | 1898 |
| Rev. Claude Shaver | 1902-1903 |
| Rev. Frank Hoyt | 1905 |
| Rev. Emanuel Schultz | 1905 |
| Rev. Robertson | 1906-1909 |
| Newton Mettler (student) | 1909 |
| R.J. Blue (student) | 1909 |
| Rev. Cline H. Witteman | 1909-1910 |
| Rev. A.S. Wright | 1910-1914 |
| Rev. O.H. Frerking | 1914-1918 |
| Rev. Robert L. Vance | 1919-1922 |
| Rev. E. Jones | 1923-1927 |
| Rev. B.F. Pickering | 1928-1931 |
| Rev. Herbert Marsh | 1933-1934 |
Rev. R.J. Blue | 1935-1940 |
Rev. Carl Sinning | 1940-1950 |
| Rev. Shock (Interim) | 1942-1944 |
| Rev. J.H. Thaden | 1951-1957 |
Rev. M.D. Kruse | 1957-1962 |
| Rev. Ray Willemssen | 1962-1969 |
Rev. LeRoy Sankey | 1970-1977 |
Rev. Douglas R. Ganyo | 1977-1981 |
Rev. Howard Stepaneck (Interim) | 1981-1982 |
Rev. Frank Elliot | 1982-1989 |
| Rev. Ron Hawkins | 1989-1990 |
| Rev. Randall Knuth | 1990-1995 |
| Rev. R. Michael McDowell (Interim) | 1995-1996 |
| Rev. Kenneth MacLeod | 1996-1999 |
| Rev. Donna Gray | 2000-2008 |
| Rev. Duane Queen (Honorably Retired) | 2010-2012 |
Rev. Tim Harmon | 2012-2019 |
